Tug Of War: Diesel Power vs. Tesla Power

For those not familiar with carwow, it's a British YouTube channel designed to bring together buyers and sellers of new and used cars. It achieves this, in part, by means of its YouTube platform. The videos fall into the category of edutainment. That is, they educate viewers while simultaneously entertaining them.

Many of the videos are comparisons. You can see drag races comparing speed or tug of war videos which feature power. Some are simply in-depth profiles of fancy vehicles like the latest Rolls Royce.

On Tuesday, Inside EVS (insideevs.com) got excited by a carwow video involving a diesel-powered Land Rover that tangled in a tug-of-war with a Tesla-powered Land Rover. The article, written by Steven Loveday, begins with this exclamation: "What a concept?" Actually, that punctuation mark should be an exclamation: What a concept!

Can an EV defeat a diesel bull in a head-to-head (or tail-to-tail) power game? That is what everyone is checking in to see. 

The video features Mat Watson, whose English brogue is so thick you can cut it with a chainsaw, explaining all the details so that we understand the parameters of this exhibition. Watson serves as narrator and host.

We're all familiar with the tug-of-war concept. There's a rope and the two vehicles are securely fastened, facing opposite directions. In this case we have a new Land Rover Defender vs. an older Land Rover powered by a Tesla electric motor and battery pack. 

When he lifts the hood you see the size of the motor and in the rear you see the space filled with battery. Not much space for luggage if you're heading out on a family vacation, but that's not the point here. 

One reason the diesel was selected for this face-off is because diesels have been the vehicle of choice when it come to towing. Long haul trucking is diesel dependent as well, at least for now. In this instance we're looking at daily drivers.

People who favor diesel-powered light trucks aren't choosing diesel simply for the towing capacity. Diesel engines are more durable, lasting longer and providing more trouble-free service. Even so, they do have a reputation for low-end torque. Loveday notes that even "high-tech turbocharged engines and hybrid systems have proven they can tow more."

For this specific competition carwow had to modify an old Land Rover because there aren't any all-electric pickup trucks or capable EV SUVs available. The modified Land Rover gives viewers a chance to see a head to head with similar structures.

SPOILER ALERT

Since this is an EV website we're reading this on, you might assume that the diesel will end up on the losing end, but the script has a few twists. There are two Tesla-powered vehicles in this story. The diesel Land Rover will defeat the Tesla Land Rover fairly easily. But an analysis of the defeat seems to indicate that the Tesla lacked sufficient body mass to give adequate traction.

To solve that problem, they replace the standard Rover with a larger, heavier Land Rover. This beast also has some serious tread on its wheels. EV fans were all cheering no doubt when this Tesla-powered machine kicked up dirt and pulled the diesel Rover backwards across the line. 

It's not an entirely apples-to-apples comparison, but the exhibition does show how far EV power has come. Seeing that Elon Musk's SpaceX launched four humans into outer space yesterday, you might say that this has been a very special week for Tesla. 

It doesn't mean the premature end of diesel, however. It only means that we're in a very different period in history.

Here's the video of that tug-of-war. Check it out. It's fun.
https://insideevs.com/news/533058/gas-vs-tesla-power-tugofwar/

Check Out These Related Tug-Of-War Battles:

⠀ Watch Tug Of War: Tesla Model X Vs Mercedes G550 4x4 Squared

 

⠀ Watch Tesla Model X Tug Of War Battle Against Army Hummer, Ford F-450

This Custom-Designed Diesel-Powered Land Rover Served Britain's Prince Philip Well

Photo Steve Parsons. Getty Images. No copyright infringement intended.

With our editors on vacation, we're re-posting a few of our favorite stories from the previous year. This story, published this spring, caught a lot of eyeballs. 

Funerals are a pretty big deal when it comes to the rich and famous. This is especially so when royalty is involved That is why we saw news stories from nearly every angle regarding the the funeral of Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh. Most of these were articles about the life of Philip, of course, but also articles detailing the history of royal funerals through the decades, the dress code for such funerals, the things that are different from normal because of the pandemic, decisions made that may be unexpected, guest lists and other details that must be attended to.

And then there is the story of Prince Philip's custom-designed diesel-powered Land Rover that will serve as his hearse. 

I've heard of people building their own coffins, but this is the first time I've ever heard about a personally-designed hearse. It is a Land Rover that the prince has been tweaking for 16 or 18 years, depending on which news source your read. Either way, it's actually quite a story.

The Duke driving a Land Rover with the Queen in 1955.

It's well known that people who love Land Rovers really love them. They're dedicated. When Prince Philip began to consider his mortality, and all the fanfare that goes along with royal funerals, he simultaneously began sowing the seeds for a no-frills funeral, starting with the hearse itself. "Just stick me in the back of a Land Rover and driver me to Windsor," he purportedly told the Queen.

Specific decisions made by Prince Philip include the military green paint job, the open top rear, and special rubber grips on silver metal pins to hold the coffin in place. The vehicle itself is a Land Rover Defender TD5 130 chassis cab vehicle. Revealed Thursday for the first time, it generated much publicity on it own. 

According to Sky News, the Prince began the project in 2003 when he turned 82, working directly with Land Rover to get what he wanted. The selection of a 4-wheel drive Defender is intriguing. The Defender, introduced in the 1980s, was in 1998 fitted with a new 2.5-liter, five-cylinder inline turbodiesel engine badged the Td5, which replaced the Tdi in order to meet Euro III emissions regulations. Called either a straight five or an inline five, the cylinders are aligned in a row. It's both compact and efficient, using electronic control systems to produce 122 hp at 4850 rpm.  

There's symbolism in the selection of this vehicle. It's not ostentatious. It's sturdy and utilitarian, a functional vehicle for the common man. The Duke of Edinburgh was so enamored by the idea of using the Land Rover as a hearse that he made two backups in case something went wrong with the first during the intervening years from concept to this moment in time.

Here are links to stories about the hearse and the funeral:

Sky News story about the hearse designed by the Duke of Edinburgh 
Fox News story about Prince Philip's Land Rover hearse
The Royal Funeral
Telegraph feature on the Royal Hearse

We have a number fresh stories lined up for next week. If you have not signed up to our feed, you can find that in the right hand column here.

Diesel World Spotlights History of Vintage Diesel Light Trucks Beginning with Those Early Land Rovers

Jim Allen's chronology of diesel-powered light trucks in America is a well-researched history of how we got to where we are today. As the saying goes, "We've come a long way, baby." The title of this Diesel World piece is Vintage Diesel Light Trucks: Part One. 

Allen begins by explaining the role money plays when it comes to technology. In the beginning, diesel engines were large. Downsizing them for land transportation presented challenges. Since people use money (capital) as an investment only when they see the potential for a return on investment, the incentive to put diesel engines in cars was not there. The was no market demand at the time.

The first diesel engines, circa 1890s, were of such a size as to be suitable only for ships and stationary powerplants. It wasn't till the 1930s that they had been downsized to fit into big trucks, tractors, construction equipment and the like. Ongoing developments slowly brought the idea closer of using diesel engines for cars and light trucks. 

One of the big challenges, Allen notes, had to do with batteries. (Sidenote: We've seen this in recent decades as the world moves inexorably toward renewable energy. Batteries were heavy and expensive. The motivation to solve these problems has been high and progress is being made.)

The initial stumbling block for diesels was that cold weather depleted cranking power. Consumers had additional complaints about diesels in the past. There were noisy, smelly, rode rough and had limit rpm ranges. Add to this, the process for starting a diesel in the '40s and '50s was a pain, and they didn't deliver on power. The last nail in the coffin for diesels was the lack of filling stations that carried diesel fuel. 

As a result of these factors, Allen writes that market demand in the U.S. was 20 year behind Europe. The 1973 gas crunch, however, proved to be a big kick in the pants to move things forward. 

The funny thing is how the perception of diesel owners changed after that. Instead of being nerdy and weird, diesel owners were perceived as ahead of their time. Investment in infrastructure took place and suddenly owning a diesel was practical and made sense.

There were still hurdles to overcome for the diesel market. One of the biggest, Allen notes, was the lamentable Olds Diesels that GM introduced and sold from 1978 to '81. Since that time the diesel car market in the U.S. never recovered nor realized its potential.

All this serves as setup for a detailed chronology of diesel-powered light trucks and SUVs in the U.S. market up through the end of the '80s.

1957-73: Land Rover Series I and II Diesel SUVs and Pickups 

People who have owned Land Rovers loved them. If you've ever known a Land Rover owner, their passion for the Rover was akin to that of a cult member. 

The first Land Rover prototype was developed in 1947 using a Jeep chassis and components. The Land Rover was officially introduced in April the following year at the Amsterdam. It wasn't till 1957  that the 2.0L diesel first became an option for both the short- and long-wheelbase 4x4s. Allen writes. "It was a modern IDI design that featured roller tappets and its base architecture was also used for the OHV gas engines that replaced an aging line of low-power F-head gassers."

Unfortunately, Land Rover stopped importing to the U.S. in 1973, leaving a lot of Land Rover fans bummed for awhile. They resumed again in 1987, but without the diesel option in this market. Overseas, yes you could get your diesel-powered Land Rover, and they remained popular 'round the globe.

* * * 

To see more vintage diesel light trucks, read the full article here.

https://www.dieselworldmag.com/diesel-trucks/vintage-diesel-light-trucks-part-one/